Credibility comes to mind, but are there independant inspectors who verify the age statement.
I've always assumed the distillery attested to the age of their whiskies on some regulatory filing under the threat of pain of death, but can anyone confirm what really happens?
This means each cask will be identifiable by number, type of spirit and filling date.
Likewise, the process of bottling will be equally well recorded and if any authorities wish to check records, then they would be able to verify all details.
Yello to Mello wrote:.
That sounds right. If authorities want to check they can look at the cask's numbers and if they are suspicious they can check the specific gravity of the whisky to see if it would be correct with the starting alcoholic strength. If the distillers wanted to cheat those specific gravity numbers it means they started at a lower strength and the whisky wouldnt come out good and the taster would notice.[/quote]
It's interesting that comments on the forum are all (so far) conjecture. One would think that such an important piece of product information would be easily verifiable - but how? I've never seen a whisky journalist or enthusiast explain how exactly one can be sure that the whisky in the bottle is the age it says on the label.
I'm sure the big companies stand to lose too much to cheat - but smaller outfits? Any "insider" info welcome!
What are they going to say, "it's really a 25 not a 27yo" to the Excise?
It's in the distiller/bottlers interest to be accurate.
I once heard Richard Paterson say that the age of a whisky can be ascertained by its effect on the tongue.
Whether the flavours and tingle hit the front, middle, sides .....
I have personally tried to verfiy this, but as yet, I haven't found a pattern.
Nick Brown wrote:I think it would take an enormous amount of effort and heartache to lie about a whisky's age. There would be so many people who would know about it - warehouse workers, blenders, bottlers, managers and so on - that it would be impossible to keep silent. You'd just need one disgruntled former employee to blow the whistle and the distillery reputation would be shot to smithereens - especially if it were done on a systematic and repeated basis.
If I buy a few casks of 12 year old whisky from a distillery, bottle it, and stick on a label that says it's an 18 year old, how do I get caught out? Customs and Excise won't be looking. Distillery doesn't care. Who will blow the whistle?
It's within living memory that wine and spirit merchants sold Irish as Scotch.
And as for the "vintage" stuff Macallan tried to sell on their website (and McTears sell at auction)...!
Collector57 wrote:With respect Iain it's not really relevant. You're not the distillery so you won't be picked up by HMRC or anyone else.
The distillery is a business regulated under licensing laws of various kinds. The situation is entirely different.
Sorry for the confusion - I was using "I" hypothetically. What I meant was, if any independent whisky bottler buys some casks of whisky, what procedures are in place to ensure that he or they print the correct age on the label? I'm not suggesting I have evidence that anyone today is misleading the consumer - only asking what is to stop an unscrupulous person from doing so?
Is it based solely on the consumer's trust in the bottler's integrity, and a blind faith that someone might act as whistleblower in the event of naughtieness?
I think it's an important question. How can I judge with confidence that I am buying what it says on the label? The difference in perceived value between a 12, 18, 25 year old (and upwards!) of most brands of sms (and many blends) is considerable.
There is probably a good and simple answer to this question. Can anyone supply it?
any single cask bottling will have a definite age statement. They usually state when distilled and when bottled, although some may only give the age, or year distilled or year bottled.
Any single malt bottling will be a vatting of various casks from the same distillery and the age declared MUST be the age of the youngest whisky in the bottle. Older ones may be used, but the age statement has to declare the youngest, not the oldest and not an average of all together.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests