I've had the LOTI several times, most recently earlier this year. Whilst it's not the most exciting Ardbeg going around, its flaws and faults are not as obvious as I remember for the Lagavulin 25, so based purely on that experience, I would recommend the Ardbeg.
The Lord of the Isles I've tried a few times, and have always really enjoyed. The finish is amazing with a real chocolate taste.
If I was you, I'd buy a lottery ticket, cross my fingers and hopefully get both bottles.
Let us know which bottle you do choose
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests