- Silver Member
- Posts: 309
- Joined: Thu Dec 15, 2005 12:28 am
- Location: United States
Mr Fjeld wrote:In my opinion this is a very good whisky and surely an underrated one if you appreciate more subtle whiskies.
Agreed. It's one of my "default" choices together with Talisker 10 for malts to get if I run out of stuff in my booze closet. Silky dram with enough personality to raise eyebrows. If I have a critisism, it is that the flavours in the Dalwinnie 15 are not more expressive to rate as a "top drawer" malt. But very few OB's are IMHO.
Great value IMO!!!
- Cask Strength Gold Member
- Posts: 3644
- Joined: Mon Feb 20, 2006 9:27 pm
- Location: Galway, Ireland
Virginia Gentleman wrote:I think I want to try the Dalwhinnie 15 year old. Jim Murray scores it very high (95) and it is not very expensive. On the other hand Michael Jackson scores it very low (76). I am interested in your thoughts if you have tried it.
this was one of the very first whiskies that i drank on a regular basis. this was about ten years ago, and i liked it. but it has prbably changed a bit since then, or at least i cant say i recall it or was even qualified to give an opinion on it!! but whenevr anyone says "i want to try this" my view is then try it!!! despite some retching i tried a bottle of Tormore and it was about average to me and not nearly as bad as i expected based on input.
Even got to recognize that a good Tequila (brought by our friend) is not really too bad when our Scotch flasks finally ran dry as we paddled 70 miles around a remote Baja island.
Bob & Jill,
The best combination is to serve the Dalwhinnie ice cold with a chocolate dessert.
The best combination is to serve the Dalwhinnie ice cold with a chocolate dessert.
Try it at normal sipping temperature with chocolate ice cream. Special - very special
I always have a bottle in store. A really light, fruity dram enjoyed outdoors on warm evenings with the headyscent of meadow flowers calling last orders for the myriad busy buzzing creatures who have popped in for a quick drink after work. (Deep sigh)
ENOUGH of this and back to normal - I experienced a bit of a burn as Scotty mentioned above when I first tried it too. I think like many whiskies, it gets better having been opened for a few weeks
- Gold Member
- Posts: 531
- Joined: Wed Apr 13, 2005 3:08 am
- Location: Edmonton, Alberta
lawschooldrunk wrote:how would you guys and gals compare this to balblair 16?
I'm looking for a non-aggressive, very silky and smooth scotch for my brother who loves dalwhinnie because its smooth (he doesn't like a bite or a hot finish).
I have had a dram of Balblair 16 at a dinner party, if memory serves me, and I can't recall a thing about it. Don't take that as a critique, though - it was a while ago, before I got more serious about my whisky drinking.
You may wish to try either Glenlivet 15 or Aberfeldy 12. Neither of these get superior ratings from pro whisky tasters, I suspect because they're a little less "muscular" than what you typically think of whisky. But if you're looking for something with less "bite" than Dalwhinnie these would be what I would recommend. Both are Highland malts.
The Glenlivet 15 is kinda butterscotchy/vanilla-y with only a faint hint of spiciness, with a nice overall whisky-esque nose that isn't too heavy and a smooth finish, especially once the bottle's been opened and allowed to mellow. I foudn it's an especially nice malt to serve before a meal, because it's tasty enough to stimulate the palate, but light enough that it won't clash with the food later. This ought to cost you about the same as Dalwhinnie.
Aberfeldy 10, the single malt from Dewar's, I personally liked but I realize to many "serious" whisky drinkers it might qualify as pretty lightweight One of the professional tasting posted on this website describes it as "almost too playful to take seriously" - I wouldn't take that too seriously. It's a very light and subtle malt for sure, and certianly can be enjoyed by the right palate. It's very smooth, lightly fruity with some hint of smokiness and peatiness, and quite "heathery" so you don't forget you're drinking a Scottish whisky. I found this made a very nice nightcap whisky. This one should cost you a little less than Dlawhinnie. I got my bottle for $27, on a discount.
I take it you and your brother are American, and I understand Americans, generally speaking, have a rather different palate for whisky. I would consider Dalwhinnie a pretty American-friendly malt, and that's partly why it's been so well campaigned over here. The Glenlivet is also very popular among Americans (and has had some help via The Sopranos TV show in gaining further popularity). The Aberfeldy is a bit less well known, but I have yet found an American who has tried it and wouldn't give it some positive comments.
Scotty Mc wrote:I'm in two minds about it. My current bottling was like firewater when opened, really bad but it is slowly starting to mellow. It was like giving myself heartburn, only pouring the acid down my throat.
Now it seems to be fine, I'm hoping it was a one-off
Got my first ever DW 15 last month, and had precisely your experience. My first couple of glasses were, as I said to my wife, horrible ! Just burnt the lining from my mouth !! ..... however, some sampling in the lead up to xmas sees a more subtle whisky. Not sure how that occurred, maybe its my palate
As I have some within reach, I shall re-visit it in the next 2-3 days and report back.
Willie JJ wrote:Dalwhinnie is a lovely dram, often misunderstood because it is so easy to drink. But spend a little time with it and you'll find hidden depths. If you regard it as cheap in your locality then have a go. Don't expect it to blow your socks off; it won't. It is subtle. I don't really agree with either JM or MJ on this and I don't really like scoring. But if pressed, then personally I would think it is somewhere in the middle possibly closer to JM; maybe 88-ish.
I agree with you on this. If I had to score it, it would be 85-90, but then again, what does scores really mean? It says more of the taster's mood at the time than it does of the whisky, meoftenthinks.
It is a subtle and very nonaggressive malt. There's a time and place for every good malt, I say, and you have to be in teh proper mindset to appreciate it. I've never had a dram that was "firewater" as one poster mentioned. Being in the US, Dalwhinnie is a contender on the market because it can compete taste-wise with finer bourbons and Tennessee whiskies (and cost isn't as intimidating as with some malts). It is neither too sweet nor too dry, yet it oftens has citrus notes that Americans like. I read somewhere that Dalwhinnie is the top selling (or was) Scotch single malt in the US. I do know a few Canadians and northern Americans who are devoted to Dalwhinnie, although it doesn't seem as popular here in Texas. Read whatever you wish into that.
Myself, I like Crag over Dalwhinnie when it comes to an inexpensive mellow malt. Crag tends to be more vanilla-ish, yet drier than many younger vallina-y malts, and I prefer that over Dalwhinnie's tendency towards citrus notes.
jazz lover wrote:Dalwhinnie was one of my starter
scotches years ago and I found it
Novice Scotch Fan wrote:"Starter scotch" is a good way of describing Dalwhinnie. A lot of people start with it and then progress to more robust SMS. This was true of myself.
Personally I think Dalwhinnie is not a good starter scotch. For me at least, it was one I tried early and didn't like. Too boring I thought. Once I expanded my whisky horizons and developed a bit of a palate, I changed my mind and quite enjoy it. I think its a terrific and complex Highland, though the flavors are more subtle than some. Anyway, thats my two cents
- Double Gold Member
- Posts: 1945
- Joined: Sat Sep 16, 2006 2:42 pm
- Location: Reigate, UK
I agree that Dalwhinnie is subtler than many, but has lots to offer and never disappoints, even though it isn't one of my "frontline" malts.
Funny how one can not appreciate a malt early on, then once initiiated into the "heavier" styles, come to appreciate it later. My old dad, well into his eighties(90 next year!) was having trouble getting into a bottle of Dalwhinnie, and called me from his home in Switzerland to ask my opinion/advice.
I suggested he had a small dram of Laphroaig fisrt, then try the Dalwhinnie.
He called back two days later entranced with the Dalwhinnie!
"You're a genius!" he said...(Well, I knew that already, he said modestly!)
Anyway Joe, keep posting. Always good to have new input, and meet new "cyberfaces".
I've only had one bottle, over a year ago, and I recall picking up subtle flavours that made me think there was but all the literature I've read suggests it contains only ex-bourbon matured spirit.
Collector57 wrote:The Distillers Edition certainly uses Oloroso casks...
And it's a tasty pour as well! I find the Sherry wood element in this one tends (both texturally and flavour-wise) to play off and highlight what underlying smokiness there is in the whisky.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest