My notes on the 18, fwiw:
Nose: Lots of sherry. Ground chocolate, toffee and dark treacle. Lightly briny, salty and herby. Maybe a light earthiness. Traces of mint (Kendal mint cake). Quite creamy and buttery. Hints of leather and wet dog? Hints of desiccated coconut.
Palate: Sherry again, but it's more winy than it was on the nose. Some leathery notes and dark chocolate. Brine and salt again, more so than on the nose.
Finish: Quite winy, with a little mint, orange and some treacle coming through after a few seconds. Quite flat.
A really good nose let down, I feel, by a slightly thin palate and short, flat finish, although both of these are still pretty good. Drinkable and very easy-going.
pkt77242 wrote:I was considering ordering a bottle of Springbank 18 but since I haven't really loved any Springbanks yet, I was wondering what you all though of it? I have had the 10, 10 100 proof, and 15 and found them all to be average to slightly above average.
I am not surprised at your assessment. The 15 should have been above average. Had you tasted the 12 yr 100proof, the 21 yr, 25yr or older you would be "enthralled" with the complexity of the malt! If you had the privelege of tasting a 21 yr cask strength or a 35 yr cask strength you
would be on your knees "begging for more"!
The 18 should be quite delightful I am guessing, since it is not available as yet in the US.
I think I'll pick up a bottle. They also have Hazelburn 12, which seems to be in short supply. I bought a bottle recently and thought it was very good.
disappointing and certainly not worth the asking price.
A lot of the older bottles are priced too high for most.
I would say go with the 15 yr. or the 10 yr. cask strength.
I have around 60 springers in my collection and this one is
far from my favorite..
jazz lover wrote:Aidan honestly I do not have any Hazelburn yet.
It's on my list,however I have some very nice Longrow's.
I've the Longrow 18, which I plan to open soon. That's supposed to be very good, as I'm sure you know.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests