Anyway, this employee seemed to swear by this brand however I have yet to really see any chatter about it on these boards.
For the most part it is priced in the middle of the pack where I am, but just wondering if it worth grabbing some, or if it should sit further down the list versus others?
andygaspo wrote:For the most part it is priced in the middle of the pack where I am...
...which is fairly reasonable as far as the variability of pricing of Glen Rothes in different markets goes. (It tends slightly toward a higher price bracket in my neck of the woods, for instance.)
The vintage editions can be quite tasty, showing honeyed pear fruit and limes with an underlying yet pervasive malt grassiness and even a faint touch of smokiness - just what one looks for in a classic Highland malt, in fact. For me, there certainly appears to be a modicum of high quality Sherry casked whiskies employed in the melange.
I've marginally preferred the younger vintage releases (i.e. bottled at around 12 or so years of age) over the more venerable ones, which, to my taste buds, seem to lose that exuberant fruitiness at the expense of wood-influenced dryness.
We are now at the third generation of Select Reserve and it was a big improvement since the first Release. How can you see the diffrences between the SRs?
The first one was released with 40% and old label, than it got 43% with old label and now the third is with 43% and new Label. The fruit flavor is more present in the actual release. In the past releases it was more citrus related.
@Fscott: Serge from the Maniacs wrote about the new 1998 Vintage:Glenrothes 1998/2009 (43%, OB, Asia) Colour: gold. Nose: classic Glenrothes! No excessive youth but a very pleasant liveliness, starting on typical 'yellow' flowers (dandelions and buttercups), light honey (acacia for instance) and some almondy/nutty notes that we don't find in older versions. Goes on with notes of Sauternes wine (quite some ripe apricot) and a lot of butterscotch, vanillas and cappuccino and finally just a little wood smoke and an extra 'youth' kick between fresh big oranges and ripe strawberries. It actually noses more like a 15yo than like a 10/11yo Glenrothes and in that sense reminds me of a 1985/1997 that I enjoyed mucho at the time. Mouth: starts a bit shy and narrow but that doesn't last for long. Quite some honey and marmalade, other 'orangey stuff', ripe apples, toasted bread, lemon marmalade then cinnamon and nutmeg from the wood. Candy sugar. Rather medium-bodied and rather easy-sipping. Finish: not very long but clean, mainly on honey and a little vanilla fudge. Comments: the nose was much to my liking, the palate as well but just a little more oomph would have been welcome. Maybe a perfect whisky to quaff with food? SGP:421 - 84 points. (26 June 2009)
For further questions regarding Glenrothes don't hestitate to ask me, or if you are familar with your german language visit me on http://www.glenrothes-info.de
Some Tasting Notes on my page are in English, too.
Character: Lemon citrus, rich vanilla cinnamon hints
Checked: John Ramsay 17/12/98
Approved: Gordon Motion 11.2.09
My opinion about the 1998:
It is a great fruity Single Malt with the typical vanilla notes. I am having more yellow fruits (mirabelle, peach) not so much citrus as on the label and never found cinnamon. Honey is also present and the flavour of toast bread.
I like it soo much Well done Gordon Motion!
The biggest misunderstood in reading the label! On my page under Label I am having a german explanation about it. http://www.glenrothes-info.de/label.html
Means in english regarding the 1984 Vintage:
Approved: R.H.Fenwick 8.9.95
Approved: R.H.Fenwick 2.12.94
Approved: R.H.Fenwick 16.3.02
The approved day are not bottled dates! These are the dates when the Master Destiller approved that this Vintage is ready to release. The bottled year is under the Vintage Year in the quarter.
In your case the 1984 were bottled in the year 1995,1996,1997,2002,2003,2004 and 2005. After 2005 their were no more cask from 19884 available to create this unique Vintage.
Hope this was helpful?
Regarding Glenrothes: If you have any kind of question do not hestitate to ask.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 8 guests