As I would like to buy a few bottles to expand my single malt collection, I would kindly ask you, if you could give me some recommendations?
In general, I would like to expand my collection to get a bigger variety.
My collection so far:
Lagavulin 16, Laphroaig 15, Ardbeg 17, Talisker 10, Gelnkinchie10, Oban14, Dalwhinnie15, Glendronach12, Macallan12, Balvenie Double Wood12, Balvenie Founders Reserve 10, Springbank10, Glenmorangie Sherry, Glenmorangie Port, Glenmorangie Madeira, Glenmorangie Burgundy, MacLeods Rare, Blair Athol12, Dailuaine
I'm really looking forward to your recommendations!
By the way, coming home from a short trip to Scotland, I found some good prices in the duty free shop at the airport edinburgh:
I bought four 1 liter bottles for 22 pounds each. Thought that's pretty cheap, isn't it? That's why I have a lot of the Glenmorangie Wood finishes... If anyone of you knows how to contact passengers that fly from Edinburgh to Cologne/germany to look out for such special offers at the airport edinburgh and bring some bottles from time to time to the airport to Cologne/Germany I would be very pleased!!
Greetings to you all !
Patric Louis - Cologne/Germany
Any recommendations depend on what you want the whisky for. Is it for your own tasting, or for guests, or to impress people? I would recommend including Ardbeg, Bruichladdich, Highland Park, Glenmorangie and Macallan. You seem to have most of these.
The 15yr old Bruichladdich would provide variation. The Highland Park is a well known and well respected malt, but the bottling to get would depend on your pocket book. You also don't have any lowland - Glenchinchie perhaps? And no laid-back speysides are present. Tomintowl and Tammnavulin I've tried and like. Abelour (sp?) may be a better bet for the money.
I would definatly recommend another non-Islay island malt for balance other than Talisker. Preferably something less pungent for comparison. I'm having trouble coming up with anything other than Jura, which I wouldn't recommend to anyone - better whiskies out there for the same price.
The only other thing I can think of are highland malts with "island" character such as Clynelish or Scapa. And if you want an Islay with less peat than the big three, but with more than Bruichladdich, then Bowmore might do the trick.
The 15yr old Bruichladdich would provide variation. The Highland Park is a well known and well respected malt, but the bottling to get would depend on your pocket book. (snip)
The 15YO Bruichladdich is a good idea - recently tried it and enjoyed it a lot. As is the HP - personally the 18YO is one of my favourite whiskies of all time (currently no 1 Scotch number 3 whisky) - so obviously I would favour that expression.
'Laid back' Speysides are just not my cup of tea. Takes all sorts etc.
I hope you drink some of these (if not all).
Also, why not add some of the older or more complex Glenfiddichs? i.e. Glenfiddich Solera Reserve, Glenfiddich 18yo, etc. Perhaps these qualify as the "laid back Speysiders" that others suggest you need. A collection without a fundamental malt like Glenfiddich is a curious affair, although I can understand anyone leaving the Special Reserve 12yo on the shelf.
Personally, I think your present collection is actually pretty well rounded and I don't think you're really missing much at all. Having a Perthshire malt in there like Blair Athol is particularly impressive. But I agree with others that a Highland Park should really make the list.
Perhaps you would be interested in seeking alternative bottlings, i.e. independent bottlings (I notice all of yours are currently official distillery bottlings), or cask-strength bottlings. Many of the independent bottlers (i.e. Mackillops Choice, Blackadder etc) actually bottle at cask-strength anyway, so you could kill two birds with one stone.
I have many of what you have, and then decided to start a collection, namely rare hard to find single malts that may never be distilled again. In the last few years have managed to obtain Brora (stupendous), Port Ellen (everything promised) and Rosebank, as well as a few internationals such as Glen Breton and Wiltonshire? (The old Lammerlaw), but the last two were disapointing.
Also you may want to check out the Irish single malt Connemara.
From 'Scotch Whisky' by Charles Maclean.
Imagine a cheap, young blend, with loads of caramel, dark colour but thin flavour, way too much vanilla (i.e. a lot of grain and not much malt), no complexity, just a wonderfully dull, bland, run-of-the-mill blend.
Then imagine something much worse than that, and you have McCallums!
Was going thru the list of the top selling spirits in the world and if I remember right, 5 of the top 10 were white spirits.
Guess it has to do with the yuppies prefering bacardi and its ilk... and also I guess there are a lot more vodka and rum based cocktails which are popular esp among the women folk.
I like beer, and usually beer gives me a taste for whisky. I also like red wine, but don't particularly like most white wines. I had a gewurztraminer a few years ago that was nice and spicy, but other than that, most whites taste pretty bad to me.
I drink lots of Canadian whisky and coke, and a bit of rum finds its way in me too.
"What do you folks drink other than whisky?
I, for one, cannot drink anything else but beer (which is often followed by whisky). The best of wines or vodka just does not appeal to me".
For me, I like a good Tequila or Mezcal as much as good whisky. My problem is that whiskies are much more available (and reasonably priced) than the others. I do like the odd glass of red. For social outings, Guinness or Grolsh (especially in the hot summer).
However never the wretched lesser white spirits or those evil sweet coolers commonly refered to here as 'b*tch pop'.
After spending so much time developing my nose whenever I encounter a glass of white wine all I can detect is sour notes & vinegar.
I generally stick to single malts as there are so many flavour and nosing notes to discover. Even JW Red in a small brandy snifter with a bit of water is superior to a lot of the rubbish that is out there.
Here ends the rant.
You folks are seriously dedicated to Whisk(e)y!
I am something of a newcomer and must admit it is becoming a real passion. However I do enjoy wine regularly, especially with food. I am surprised how many of you dont like it.
Other than that, it's pretty much beer for me too. Cheaper and easier to knock back a few of than whisk(e)y. Especially in hot weather.
It was cognac first for me then finally tried a good single malt and the obsession started. Tried a cognac for the first time in a while recently and was amazed at just how fruity it tastes after drinking Talisker and Aberlour for a couple of months.
- Triple Gold Member
- Posts: 2503
- Joined: Mon Mar 25, 2002 2:01 am
- Location: Guelph, Ontario, Canada
Squire, I used to drink some cognac too but now I'm pretty much just a single malt scotch whisky man. Still drink the odd Canadian whisky and try a bourbon now and then but aside from Redbreast and Jameson 18 I'm mostly here for the scotch. Sure, I'll have a beer and wine once in a while but generally only with guests!
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest