(P.S. This poll will be far more useful and interesting if votes are accepted only by people who have tried all three. If you've only tried one or two of them, please feel free to post a comment, but may I suggest you abstain from casting a vote?)
(Edit:) My vote goes to Macallan CS the older white box with red stripes over the Glenfarclas 105, which came second, followed by Aberlour A'Bunadh batch 13 in last place. Surprising, as I would have chosen the A'Bunadh first and the Glenfarclas second based on flavour memory alone.
A humbled Muskrat Portage.
The a'Bunadh have it's strenght in that it comes out in different Batches which also make it more collectable and sought after for tasters. It´s more individual so to speak...
IMHO of course...
MrTattieHeid wrote:Musky, try them again in a different order. In fact, try every possible permutation:...Then spend an evening with each by itself. I have a suspicion that context changes everything, ...
Mr. T. you bring up a valid point or three. I will revisit these three again and do it blind to see what happens. Possibly I should also sample the 13, 14 and 15 batches? Musky Pete
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 7 guests